Skip to main content

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

45% Milk Chocolate

(2 reviews) Write a Review
  • Milk
  • Kosher
  • Gluten Free
  • Candy
  • Peanut Butter
  • consumer


A childhood favorite, made better than ever.

At Theo, we love a classic treat and elevating flavors to the next level of deliciousness. Our take on a classic peanut butter cup is filled with organic peanut butter wrapped in 45% milk chocolate that's unlike any you've tried before. With a higher cocoa percentage than most milk chocolate, it's creamy and smooth, with plenty of cocoa flavor to balance out the sweetness and perfectly complement roasty peanut butter.

Each pack comes with 2 heart-shaped cups. Perfect for sharing...or not!

•Organic   •Fair for Life   •Soy Free

•Palm Free   •Kosher   •Gluten Free


Democratic Republic of Congo


Peanut Butter (Roasted Peanuts)*, Cocoa Butter*+, Cane Sugar*+, Cocoa Beans*+, Powdered Sugar* (Cane Sugar*+, Cornstarch*), Whole Milk Powder*, Peanut Flour*, Sea Salt, Rosemary Extract*^. CONTAINS PEANUTS & MILK.


Individuals with Food Allergies: Made on equipment that also processes tree nuts, eggs, & wheat.

Kosher Dairy certification logo
Fair for life fair trade certification logo
Organic is always non GMO certification logo
USDA Organic certification logo

2 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Forced to by direct

    Posted by Jason on Feb 11th 2020

    These are the only peanut butter cups I like and no now one within a 120 miles radius sells them so I buy direct from Theo. Ordered twice so far a fresh each time! Highly recommended.

  • 5
    Peanut Butter Cups

    Posted by Stacey on Feb 6th 2020

    These heart-shaped peanut butter cups are ahhhmazing!