Skip to main content

Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

85% Dark Chocolate

(9 reviews) Write a Review
  • Dark
  • Kosher
  • Vegan
  • Gluten Free
  • Candy
  • Extra Dark


Super dark and super decadent. Rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter blended together in an 85% dark chocolate shell for a treat unlike any you’ve had before.

•Organic   •Fair for Life   •Non-GMO

•Soy Free   •Vegan   •Gluten Free   •Kosher   •Palm Free


Democratic Republic of Congo




Cocoa Beans*+, Peanut Butter (Roasted Peanuts)*, Powdered Sugar* (Cane Sugar*+, Cornstarch*), Cane Sugar*+, Cocoa Butter*+, Peanut Flour*, Cocoa Powder*+, Peanut Oil*, Sea Salt, Rosemary Extract*^, Ground Vanilla Bean*.


Individuals with Food Allergies: Made on equipment that also processes tree nuts, milk, eggs, & wheat.

Kosher Dairy certification logo
Fair for life fair trade certification logo
Organic is always non GMO certification logo
USDA Organic certification logo

9 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    The Whole order ~ very good!

    Posted by Gary Nelson on Oct 29th 2021

    I really have enjoyed both the dark chocolate and milk chocolate versions for the Peanut Butter Cups! I'm still waiting ('impatiently' lol) for the season/sale of the 'broken pieces'!! I really thought that was AWESOME last year!!

  • 5
    The best

    Posted by Theo's Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups on May 20th 2021

    Theo's Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are the best on the market. With superb quality and taste, they can satisfy any chocolate/peanut butter combination craving.

  • 5
    Peanut butter Cup

    Posted by Michael Blackwell on Dec 31st 2020

    Theo Chocolate always delivers. Stocking stuffers were all Theo this year. The remaining chocolate bars will be dipped in CB's Nuts Peanut butter tonight for New Year's!

  • 5

    Posted by Darcy Dillard on Aug 9th 2020

    These are best in class; why are they so hard to find?

  • 5
    d best

    Posted by Eric on Jul 24th 2020

    I was skeptical that 85% might be bitter or strong but ordered a couple only because 85% is good for health. Well, these turned out to be the BEST peanut butter chocolate I have ever had. Smooth, creamy, and sweetness of peanut butter balances the dark perfectly. Looking forward to 12-pack!

  • 5
    Best peanut butter cups ever

    Posted by Unknown on Mar 24th 2020

    As a dark chocolate and peanut butter fan, I really appreciate the double chocolate peanut butter cups. They are very mildly sweet and have a slight saltiness. The quality of all ingredients are well-balanced.

  • 4
    Very tasty!

    Posted by Sherrill on Feb 28th 2020

    Very tasty peanut butter cups! I never had dark chocolate peanut butter cups, so I have nothing to compare Theo's too. That's why I gave you a 4 instead of a 5. Will place an order again. Thank you!

  • 5
    double chocolate Peanut butter cup

    Posted by Jill on Feb 4th 2020

    This is one of the best peanut butter cups I've ever eaten it is dark chocolate and it is wonderful my sister who is hypoglycemic can eat them because they are low in sugar and they taste fantastic

  • 4
    Rather just have peanut butter

    Posted by Marcee Hampton on Dec 19th 2019

    I just purchased these when I made an order to fill my stocking...which I have to say will be an annual tradition from now on. I did not realize when I added them to the cart that they were chocolate and peanut butter combined for the center. I saw double chocolate peanut butter cup and thought twice the cup and still a plain peanut butter center. I was very excited. They are still good....but I would prefer them with the 85 percent dark cup and plain peanut butter in the center. I like the salty peanut butter to go along with the sweet 85 percent chocolate. Cant go wrong with plain ol chocolate and peanut butter.