Skip to main content

Peppermint Polly

Flagship Treat

(9 reviews) Write a Review
  • Dark
  • Gluten Free
  • Kitchen Confection


Creamy mint filling enrobed in dark chocolate. Now that’s a cool classic. Our Peppermint Polly is the perfect refreshing treat to add to your day. Handmade in our Confection Kitchen by our team of chocolatiers, using our rich dark chocolate, this delicious treat is exclusively available on and in our Flagship Store.

Checkout the rest of our Flagship Treats!

•Soy Free   •Gluten Free  


Democratic Republic of Congo




Cane Sugar*+, Cocoa Beans*+, Corn Syrup*, Water, Cocoa Butter+, Contains two percent or less of: Whole Milk Powder*, Peppermint Essential Oil*. CONTAINS MILK. 


Individuals with Food Allergies: Made on equipment that also processes peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, wheat, & sesame.

9 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    The best!!

    Posted by Danielle on Jan 24th 2023

    The best chocolate peppermint treat ever, I hate to leave such a positive review because I don’t want them to run out of stock…they are that good!!

  • 5
    Best Pepperment Pattie EVER

    Posted by KM on Jun 23rd 2022

    Real peppermint filling enrobed in rich chocolate - no skimping on flavor or unnecessary artificial fillings

  • 5
    Peppermint Polly

    Posted by Elaenor on Nov 9th 2021

    Mint chocolate is a favorite combination and Theo's Peppermint Polly is a mountain of flavor satisfaction!

  • 5
    Peppermint Polly

    Posted by Margaret on Mar 16th 2021

    Absolutely wonderful, especially for vegans who miss that other round, chocolate-covered peppermint treat that is not vegan!!

  • 5
    Peppermint Polly

    Posted by Ginny on Mar 1st 2021

    Peppermint Polly has the perfect ratio of dark chocolate to peppermint goodness. I eat them alone, or I freeze and chop up to sprinkle over ice cream. So much great flavor!

  • 3
    Peppermint Polly

    Posted by Jayna on Nov 24th 2020

    This was our first time to try a Peppermint Polly, and was really looking forward to it. Unfortunately it was way to rich for my taste. The chocolate was a little uneven, to rather overly thick in the center. I think if the chocolate would have been thinner it would have settled better. I am sure, as good as Theo's products are, that there are lots of folks out there that simply adore Peppermint Polly's.

  • 5
    So good!

    Posted by virtues27 on Jul 29th 2020

    Wow! These are really good and they are large too. I wish I could buy these locally, like the chocolate bars. Glad they can be shipped.

  • 5
    Peppermint Polly

    Posted by Janice Drickey on May 12th 2020

    Peppermint Pollys are the richest, creamiest, melt-in-your-mouthiest peppermint patties on the face of the Earth! (Sorry. I can’t speak for other planets.) When a friend tipped me off that you were offering a limited supply of Peppermint Pollys, I FLEW to my computer and placed my order immediately. Now I am a happy, happy camper. Thank you. No, really. Thank you.

  • 5
    Peppermint Polly

    Posted by Ginny on Apr 24th 2020

    This is my favorite confection from Theo. It stands head and shoulders above the Peppermint Patty I used to think I liked. I hope it is back in stock soon!