Skip to main content

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cups

55% Dark Chocolate

(14 reviews) Write a Review
  • Gluten Free
  • Vegan
  • Kosher
  • Dark
  • Candy


A delicious twist on a classic duo. Creamy peanut butter layered with sweet raspberry filling in a 55% dark chocolate shell.

•Organic   •Non-GMO  •Fair for Life  

•Kosher   •Soy Free   •Gluten Free   •Vegan


Democratic Republic of Congo




Cocoa Beans*+, Cane Sugar*+, Peanut Butter (Roasted Peanuts)*, Raspberry Filling* (Tapioca Syrup*, Cane Sugar*, Water, Raspberry Juice Concentrate*, Citric Acid, Pectin), Cocoa Butter*+, Powdered Sugar* (Cane Sugar*+, Cornstarch*), Peanut Flour*, Sea Salt, Rosemary Extract*^, Ground Vanilla Bean*. CONTAINS PEANUTS.


Individuals with Food Allergies: Made on equipment that also processes tree nuts, milk, eggs, & wheat.

Kosher Dairy certification logo
Fair for life fair trade certification logo
Organic is always non GMO certification logo
USDA Organic certification logo

14 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Life Changing Treat

    Posted by Lydia on Nov 6th 2021

    These Peanut Butter & Jelly Cups are the best thing my mouth has ever come too. Please don’t ever get rid of these.

  • 5
    Peanut Butter and Jelly Cups

    Posted by Mary Jane Tala on Sep 29th 2021

    Where have these been all my life? I discovered them during a Theo virtual tasting (that was amazing, BTW), and am now addicted. The chocolate is *just* dark enough, and the raspberry jelly takes it that one step beyond plain old peanut butter cups. I am now permanently spoiled!

  • 4
    this would actually be a 3.5

    Posted by JD Estrada on Sep 22nd 2021

    If I could give half stars, I'd give this a 3.5. I enjoyed it though I was looking to see if I could find a healthier replacement for a more popular peanut butter cup. The chocolate as usual is wonderful though I think the flavors could use a little amping up in these cups.

  • 5
    Peanut butter & jelly cups

    Posted by Lorena Jones on Aug 14th 2021

    These are fantastic! Rich dark chocolate with tart (raspberry?) jelly. This combination is so rich & delightful. Great taste, hard to share with anyone.

  • 5

    Posted by Michael Klimczak on Mar 2nd 2021

    These are super yummy. It's like a gourmet version of a peanut butter cup with raspberry jelly filling. I will be buying this again.

  • 5
    Good stuff

    Posted by Me on May 22nd 2020

    Just cost too much. I can't afford to buy these as much as I'd like

  • 5

    Posted by Kaitlin Allen on Apr 22nd 2020

    These are the best peanut butter cups I have ever tried. The addition of the jelly sets these apart from every other peanut butter cup. I tried one of these in a Love With Food box and immediately bought a 12-pack.

  • 5
    PB&J in a heavenly wrapper!

    Posted by Alan Smith on Apr 8th 2020

    During this shelter in place, the only thing we have been able to look forward to is rewarding ourselves on Friday nights with a delicious Theo PB&J cup! YUM!

  • 5
    Surprisingly delicious!

    Posted by hybroanglid on Apr 4th 2020

    I didn't really expect to love these. Peanut butter AND jelly, covered in dark chocolate? But I received a free sample, and I had the munchies, so I decided to give 'em a try. WOW!! These are SO GOOD!! I love them, so much that I immediately googled the name so I could find out where to buy them. Thank you, Theo, for making such a delicious and ORGANIC yummy treat!!